naturerecordists
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: PCM Recorder advice needed.

Subject: Re: PCM Recorder advice needed.
From: "Sean" rastasean83
Date: Wed Jul 14, 2010 12:07 pm ((PDT))
I forgot to mention one thing that's probably crucial to nature recordists =
just as much as microphones and recorders, headphones.

In conjunction with the 2le, I recommend the Sennheiser HD 25-1 II headphon=
es for superior isolation and excellent sounding, quality headphones.

just another opinion...take it or leave it.



--- In  "oryoki2000" <> wrote:
>
> >  What are some of the "idiosyncrasies and quirks" of [the FR2-LE]?
>
> Here are notes from my review, posted here in July 2007. --oryoki
>
>
> First, when you format the Compactflash card for use in the FR-2LE, you s=
pecify the bit depth and quantization rate to be used (like 24/96).  These =
settings are stored in a text file on the flash card.  If you want to chang=
e this setting (say, to MP3 or 16/44.1), you have to re-format the flash ca=
rd.  The formatting will lose any data already on the flash card.  This is =
a quick format, just a few seconds.
>
> Second, the maximum file size is 4GB.  When the recorder gets to 4GB, it =
just saves the file and stops.  4GB is space for six hours of continuous re=
cording in 16/48, but only two hours at 24/96.  This is not an issue for mo=
st nature recording scenarios, but could be a problem if the recorder will =
do double duty as a concert recorder.
>
> Third, the FR-2LE has only one bit depth for MP3.  It's 192kbps continuou=
s (no variable rate).  Recording at this rate, a 1GB card can hold approxim=
ately 11 hours of recordings.  You'd need to change batteries or run from a=
n external power supply to record for such a long time.
>
> Fourth, you can't erase any tracks from the machine in the field.  You ca=
n remove tracks from the edit decision list, or change the order of the tra=
cks in the list, but you can't delete any.  When you attach your flash card=
 to a computer, you can delete if you want to.  Or you can format the card =
in the recorder.  But an individual file can't be deleted in the recorder.
>
> Fifth, the FR-2LE records in stereo only.  This is wasteful of storage sp=
ace if you are recording with a single mic.  I guess you could use a "Y" ca=
ble to send the mono signal into both channels of the recorder, and then re=
cord at different preamp levels.
>
> I think these last two design decisions are part of a strategy Fostex has=
 to reduce errors when the machine is being used by a less-experienced reco=
rdist, perhaps a news reporter.  An audio technician sets up the recorder, =
including the flash card, in the shop.  The FR-2LE stores settings like ALC=
 on/off, high pass filter on/off, Input mode, digitizing rate, phantom powe=
r on/off, and so on, in non-volatile memory that retains the settings even =
with the battery pack removed.  The Compactflash card holds information lik=
e the digitizing rate, the project name or reel number, and pointers to the=
 start and stop points of any existing tracks and cue marks.
>
> Once the FR-2LE is configured, the field recordist doesn't need to think =
about settings, just when to push the Record button.  It doesn't matter whi=
ch XLR jack a mono mic is plugged into. Most relevant settings are visible =
on the LC screen if you want to check.
>
> I'm sure Fostex worked a long time with customers like radio stations to =
come up with this fail-safe arrangement.   The FR-2LE forces you to work a =
particular way to maximize the likelihood that your recordings will come ho=
me intact, and in the format you want.  But some people will find these res=
trictions burdensome.
>
> These points aside, the FR-2LE seems to be a great machine.  The preamp i=
s quiet, the controls are easy to use, the machine is well-designed for use=
 in a shoulder bag, and the Tamiya RC3600 NiMH battery solution is good for=
 8 hours of run time.
>








<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
Admin

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the naturerecordists mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU