Beginning Birding

[Syd Curtis <>]

Hello Peter,

                No,  this is not a case of 'the grass is greener'.   There are natural pests in a tree species' home country that limit its' growth and spread.  Move it to another country where they are absent, and away it goes.  

Pinus radiata is a pretty poor specimen in its home territory on the Monterey Penisula in America.  Not at all suitable for producing saw logs.   But it is a very popular plantation species in many other countries around the world.

To an Aussie, Eucalypts in San Francisco were simply amazing when I saw them in'67.  No insect pests to kill the leading shoots,  so great long pendulous branches.  Have an idea though, that I heard that later 'Cisco had one spell of extreme cold that did for them.  Probably more by now though.

In the animal kingdom, much the same applies, of course.  Foxes, rabbits and cats in Australia; Oz possums in New Zealand.  No natural predators controlling them, so they flourish - to the detriment of natives.

Syd


> From: 
> Date: Fri, 2 May 2003 16:45:05 +1000
> To: "John McAllister" <>
> Cc: "Birding-Aus" <>, 
> Subject: Re: [BIRDING-AUS] Beginning Birding

> hmmm...South Africans planting  She-oaks as wind breaks. Australians planting Pines as wind breaks....the grass is always greener hey??? 
>
> Wonder if the chinese plant cactus's as windbreaks? and the irish, bonsai trees? <--- for the leprechauns. : )
>  
>
>
> "John McAllister" <> 
> Sent by:  
>
> 02/05/2003 04:33 PM 
> To 
> "Birding-Aus" <>, <> cc Subject Re: [BIRDING-AUS] Beginning Birding 
>
>
>
>
> Hi Peter and others 
>  
> Thanks for your great posting.  We have the same problem here in South Africa with people's desires to emulate a sort of second rate northern hemisphere home and have plenty of House Sparrows, Common Starlings, Chaffinches (not too successful though and restricted to Cape Town), Common Mynas and Indian House Crows to name but a few. 
>  
> We have another problem too though - Australian trees!  Unlike the Aussies South Africans have a sick (for us at least) love affair with eucalypts, Australian acacias (our are obviously not good enough) and casuarinas which are used for all sorts of things from massive plantations in our grasslands to windbreaks and avenues lining farm driveways.  This has a profound effect on our bird life.  Here where I live in relatively pristine grasslands an unpublished study has shown that we have around 190 species of birds per square kilometre.  In the quite nearby agricultural areas and tree plantations this figure drops to around 110 and 70 respectively.  Studies in Kenya have shown a similar difference between indigenous forests and encroaching eucalypt plantations.  So don't despair - someone loves Australian trees - just not Australians it seems :-( 
>  
> Cheers 
>  
> John McAllister
> Beautiful Just Birding
> Wakkerstroom 
> South Africa
>