naturerecordists
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: New Soundscapes & realism

Subject: Re: New Soundscapes & realism
From: "Robin" escalation746
Date: Thu Jan 12, 2012 10:44 am ((PST))
I wrote:

> "Surely by now people realise that nothing called
> "nature" can possibly exist outside a cultural context?"

So John Hartog wrote:

> What does that even mean?

I take a walk in a local forest and decide to make a recording. The forest =
did not exist before it was constructed by humans, in the literal sense tha=
t almost no primeval / original forest remains in Europe. All such places I=
 might choose to occupy are a result of agricultural practices. The walk is=
 along a designated path. Even if I vary from this, the floor of the forest=
 is very unlike that in an untamed woods, being largely cleared of detritus=
. If I am very adventurous, I might explore deep thickets that relatively f=
ew people have traversed, but even there I might be surprised to find disca=
rded refuse and (as all in this group are aware) the sonic traces of overhe=
ad aircraft, distant automobiles, water craft, and so on.

In my attempt to escape all this and seek a "peaceful", "untouched", "virgi=
n" experience I must remove myself further, but even then can only accompli=
sh my task if I am willing to forget that these concepts are a product of p=
articular aesthetic preoccupations, philosophies and artistic movements of =
the past. The very idea of "taking a walk in nature" is a construct.

As is the idea of "noise", by the way. One listener's annoyance is another =
listener's salve.

> Reality cannot exist outside of a cultural context.

I am not sure how this argument is furthered by making it so general that i=
t cannot possibly be addressed. I believe your gambit it congruent with the=
 "straw man" fallacy.

> The word "nature" might however have a specific meaning
> in the context of this group.

The variety of responses in this thread demonstrates otherwise.

I come to a social milieu such as the one provided by this group precisely =
so my expectations might be challenged. Here I can see/hear from other pers=
pectives. I am as happy to hear your coyotes echoing through Oregon as I am=
 Mark's icebreaker. Both are part of fictional worlds that have only some v=
ague relationship to lived experience. And none whatsoever to mine. Which i=
s precisely why they are worth listening to.

-- robinparmar.com







<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
Admin

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the naturerecordists mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU