birding-aus

Cooktown Slaty-backed Gull happily post sittingtoday

To: "'Nikolas Haass'" <>, "'Mike Carter'" <>, "'Tony Russell'" <>, "'BIRDING-AUS'" <>, "Alan McBride" <>, "Alvaro Jaramillo" <>, "'Andrew Silcocks'" <>, "Bill Ramsay" <>, "Chris Corben" <>, "Danny Rogers" <>, "David James" <>, <>, "Keith & Lindsay Fisher" <>, "Lisa Hug" <>, "Michiaki Ujihara" <>, "Mike Carter" <>, "'Nial Moores'" <>, "'Nikolas Haass'" <>, "'Paul Walbridge'" <>, "richard baxter" <>, "'Robert Inglis'" <>, "Rohan Clarke" <>, "Sean Dooley" <>, "Simon Mustoe" <>, "'TED SHIMBA'" <>, "'Tom Tarrant'" <>, "'Tony Palliser'" <>
Subject: Cooktown Slaty-backed Gull happily post sittingtoday
From: " Jeff Davies" <>
Date: Sat, 23 Feb 2008 20:02:02 +1100
G'day Nikolas,

I think DNA would be fine but its an issue as to how this is achieved and
who would pay for it. I'm still more interested in knowing what is left to
stand in the way of it being a Slaty-back, I think that's where the
discussion should go from here.

Cheers Jeff.

-----Original Message-----
From: 
 On Behalf Of Nikolas Haass
Sent: Saturday, 23 February 2008 7:06 PM
To: Mike Carter; Tony Russell; BIRDING-AUS
Subject: Cooktown Slaty-backed Gull happily post
sittingtoday

Hi Mike and Jeff,

What I wanted to say with my provocative mail is that we obviously had
problems ID'ing this bird. For me it still could very well be a Slaty-back
and I also pointed out earlier that I don't like to call everything a hybrid
that I can't ID - but did we really rule out a hybrid? I do agree that many
features speak for Slaty-back and that's why I initially ID'd it as such.
However, several others vehemently ruled out Slaty-back (because of color
and pattern of scaps and mantle feathers, because of the size and shape of
the bill and I think there were more mentioned). So apparently it is not a
'straight-forward' ID. So after all this confusing back and forth, I really
would be curious about the results of a DNA analysis!

Nikolas
 
----------------
Nikolas Haass

Sydney, NSW


----- Original Message ----
From: Mike Carter <>
To: Nikolas Haass <>; Tony Russell <>;
BIRDING-AUS <>
Sent: Saturday, February 23, 2008 6:08:40 PM
Subject: Cooktown Slaty-backed Gull happily post sitting
today

Nikolas Haass <> said today
To: "Tony Russell" <>; "Mike Carter" 
<>; "BIRDING-AUS" <>


> Although I was the first one who dared to ID the bird as a female 
> first-winter Slaty-backed Gull (see old posting below), I still would NOT 
> say that we 'SETTLED' on a definite ID.
> We clearly ruled out Thayer's Gull, American Herring Gull (see below), the

> fuscus complex including Heuglin's Gull (heuglini and taimyrensis), 
> Eurasian Herring Gull, and most of the "yellow-legged gull complex". 
> Moreover, as I indicated a week ago, tail and primary patterns speak 
> against Mongolian and Steppe Gull.
> And also Vega doesn't fit 100%. But - although it was my favorite - does 
> Slaty-back fit 100%? No, it looks good for a Slaty-back, but apparently 
> not 100%! Look at all the divergent comments from experts from all over 
> the world! I think, the final ID at this point should be "possible 
> Slaty-back".
>
> Nikolas

So although you named it several days ago, you are still not 100% convinced?
Please tell us what you consider unsatisfactory in that ID.

Jeff Davies and I will prepare the BARC submission and we are confident that

we can totally justify that diagnosis. Among significant aspects that you 
didn't address were the plain dark underwing pattern and short primary 
projection beyond tail. Once those two features fell into place for 
Slaty-backed ruling out Vega Gull the one remaining stumbling block was the 
scapular pattern which was more typical of Vega Gull. But now we know some 
Slaty-backs can be similarly patterned there are no contra-indications. The 
presence of that second generation secondary feather noted by Alvaro was a 
bonus. All discriminators are in favour of Slaty-backed Gull. QED.

Mike Carter
30 Canadian Bay Road
Mount Eliza  VIC 3930
Tel  (03) 9787 7136


 
____________________________________________________________________________
________
Looking for last minute shopping deals?  
Find them fast with Yahoo! Search.
http://tools.search.yahoo.com/newsearch/category.php?category=shopping
===============================
www.birding-aus.org
birding-aus.blogspot.com

To unsubscribe from this mailing list, 
send the message:
unsubscribe 
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
to: 
===============================

===============================
www.birding-aus.org
birding-aus.blogspot.com

To unsubscribe from this mailing list, 
send the message:
unsubscribe 
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
to: 
===============================

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
Admin

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the birding-aus mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU