Hopefully Laurie, the lack of discussion on the Wonga Beach incident means that
everyone agreed that it was a bad thing, but on the other hand, there are
different ways to look at the Balanagara proposal, both showing some merit.
To some on the forum, the opinions expressed against Balanagara seem very harsh
(we all know though, that emails don't come with the benefit of voice cues and
facial expressions, so are easily misjudged), so they naturally go to their
defence, because the cause seems good in principle and grew from principles we
The Wong Beach incident can be looked at in the some way to some degree, since
we all enjoy looking at birds, however, those folk went about a noble endeavour
in the wrong way. It may not be as confronting, but I think many are just
saying Balanagara went about a good cause in the wrong way??
On 19/11/2011, at 11:08 AM, Laurie Knight wrote:
> The discussion regarding the bulk posting from Balanagara soliciting funds
> for it's lyrebird DVD production provides an interesting insight into the
> online birding community.
> It appears that the one thing that we dislike the most is being asked for
> money :)
> One of the most annoying things about walking through the CBD are the
> fundraisers on the street trying to get us to sign up for regular financial
> contributions to their worthy cause. We develop the ability to walk
> purposefully so they know we aren't going to "buy" (and then they remember
> not to look hopefully at us the next day when we pass them again).
> The thing is that you never know whether people are what they say, so you
> develop a natural suspicion of everyone asking for something, particularly if
> they are doing in online, and especially if they are "cold calling".
> Anyhow, it is interesting to compare the length of the tread on the
> Balanagara spam to the follow-up to Del Richard's post about birders behaving
> badly at Wonga Beach. The behaviour of the birders intruding on private
> property to twitch the Spotted Whistling Ducks illustrates an important
> "cultural" issue that needs to be addressed by the birding community.
> However, we don't want to talk about that. We want to twitch Hoopoes and
> avoid fundraisers.
> The interesting thing about online forums like birding-aus is that they don't
> appear to have a basis to reach and record consensus on issues like birder
> behaviour, fundraising and organised activities ...
> Regards, Laurie.
> To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
> send the message:
> (in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
send the message:
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)