Hi Michael--
Searching the list archive it seems there have been quite a few folks
who were surprised by the unannounced "field playback" policy. Maybe
there is a statement somewhere that I'm missing?
I find your wording to be a good start towards text that could be
added either to the list description or another page of list related
FAQ's. Other list participants will have to chime in for us to
address a possible change this in a semi-democratic way. Rob D.
=3D =3D =3D =3D =3D =3D
At 12:53 PM +1100 10/15/08, Michael Gallagher wrote:
>Dear Naturerecordists,
>
>I agree with the moderator's determination to steer discussion away from
>field playback, for I believe it has the potential to seriously
>disrupt bird
>lives when used carelessly. When I read accounts involving use of the
>technique
>by researchers or bird observers, I often feel that the benefits
>gained do not
>outweigh the potential for seriously disrupting bird lives.
>
>We are still largely ignorant about animal communication and the
>functions of
>calls. Much research has yet to be done, and many methods will need
>to be
>employed, including use of playback, But, I believe that should be
>restricted
>to tightly controlled research enclosures and laboratories, and be
>monitored
>by responsible ethical standards committees.
>
>For the most part, Naturecordists discusses techniques for recording
>in natural
>environments. I believe, along with most other group members, I
>assume, that
>field playback to call birds in, should generally not be used in natural
>environments.
>
>In responding to requests for information about field playback, I
>believe we
>should inform requesters of our concerns regarding its use.
>
>Perhaps a member could prepare a statement that specifies why this
>topic is not
>generally discussed in this forum that could be sent in response to such
>queries.
>
>Perhaps we should add a statement regarding our position on field
>playback to
>the introductory statement on the home page.
>
>Regards
>
>Michael Gallagher
>Bendigo, Victoria, Australia
>
>
--
|