John Campbell wrote:
>>As a matter of procedure, could everybody refrain from titling all
>>minidisc problems as ATRAC problems? Those titles are with us forever in
>>the archives of the internet, people searching about ATRAC artifacts
>>will have them all pop up. Some don't even bother to read what's said,
>>just count how many hits they find and call that evidence of flaws in
>>ATRAC compression.
>>
>>Walt
>>
>
>
>
> May I ask what evidence you have to substantiate this claim? Who are
> these "some"?
Do a search on ATRAC artifacts, then track the source of each
statement. Particularily in public forums you will find that a lot.
I have personally had considerable private email over the years of folks
who do exactly what I describe. They will say something like I found "X"
number of articles on ATRAC artifacts, they must be a big problem.
Then go on from there.
I was commenting on a post that was about a minidisc problem that had
nothing to do with ATRAC compression. Do you feel all such posts should
be titled "ATRAC artifacts"?
Walt
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
|