|To:||"'Peter Shute'" <>|
|Subject:||Peregrine Falcons on Bondi VET(Channel 10 TV)|
|From:||"Philip Veerman" <>|
|Date:||Mon, 25 Nov 2013 16:18:41 +1100|
Thanks all for your input (to me and the lists). I was wondering would anyone be interested. I'm glad I asked……. I later added this text:
(both showing all the features of juvenal plumage - striped, rather than barred underparts, underparts colours especially the throat, orangey-buff rather than basically white, upperparts brown rather than grey with clear rufous edgings to the back and wing covert feathers, cap brown rather than black and primary feathers too short for adults (not full grown).
I suppose he used the term "a young adult, from the plumage" very loosely. Maybe he thinks "adult" is just meaning feathered. That is a guess. It is not clear that he is aware of the plumage difference, unless a young adult is the same as juvenile.
I am simply thinking that the reluctance of the birds to fly, combined with the short wings suggests that if they had left the nest of their own choice, it was only into the first day or two post fledging. Indeed they may have only walked off the nest ledge and then were captured before they had flown. If whoever nabbed them thought they were the adults, then they might have reason to think they were suddenly sick. There were two chicks and I assume they also saw two adults (the film appeared to show one parent that was agitated, as they always are when people are near their nest). What did he think they were there for? I don't expect him to know all about birds, but my question is not so much not knowing the different plumage details and how he confused chicks for their parents, but on the grounds of pure logic that the story as presented makes no sense.
Yes I agree: the last minute of the show. One flew off and began soaring (not very well), the other glided to the roof of a nearby building. That seemed like a risky process with birds that might not be able to fly, but might be frightened enough to try. I also thought the feeding of them what looked like cut pieces of beef (whilst holding them almost upside down) was odd, but as a short term feeding can't do much harm, but it isn't an adequate diet.
Against my better judgement, I just watched it on the ten website.
They had streaked breast plumage rather than barred, and at one point he said the first one was "a young adult, from the plumage", so he was aware of the plumage difference. But I wasn't able to see anything that would indicate they might not have fledged yet. Perhaps a tiny bit of down on top of the head?
I assume they couldn't be breeding in that plumage. How old would they have to be?
He may have been fooled by the fact that the building staff captured them, yet the nest was 20m below the roof of a high building. No matter where they were caught, roof or ground, they could only have flown there, yet couldn't or wouldn't fly when approached. To someone who didn't know what stage they were at, that wouldn't really add up to them being fledglings.
He may have simply believed the staff's opinion that they were the adults, and then the need to include something in the show other than more bloody dogs took over.
For those who can't be bothered watching it on the web site, all 5 minutes or so of it, interspersed with 55 minutes of ads and dog kissing, in an interface that doesn't allow fast forward or rewind, they were released on top of the building in the last minute of the show. One flew off and began soaring, the other glided to the roof of a nearby building. That seemed like a risky process with birds that might not be able to fly, but might be frightened enough to try.
The birds were fed for a few days, and one was treated with antibiotics for "thrush", so probably no harm done? Do peregrines abandon their young if they've been handled like this? Do they still feed them after fledging?
|<Prev in Thread]||Current Thread||[Next in Thread>|
|Previous by Date:||[canberrabirds] Peregrine Falcons on Bondi VET (Channel 10 TV), Peter Shute|
|Next by Date:||Franklin's Gull in Perth, John Graff|
|Previous by Thread:||[canberrabirds] Peregrine Falcons on Bondi VET (Channel 10 TV), Peter Shute|
|Next by Thread:||Peregrine Falcons on Bondi VET(Channel 10 TV), Peter Shute|
|Indexes:||[Date] [Thread] [Top] [All Lists]|
The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the birding-aus mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: firstname.lastname@example.org.EDU.AU