Azure Kingfisher and Cuckoo at Wilson Reserve, Ivanhoe, Vic.

To: "brian fleming" <>, <>
Subject: Azure Kingfisher and Cuckoo at Wilson Reserve, Ivanhoe, Vic.
From: "Bruce Cox" <>
Date: Sat, 27 Jan 2007 11:05:23 +1100
From: "brian fleming" <>
Subject: Azure Kingfisher and Cuckoo at Wilson Reserve,
Ivanhoe, Vic.

Hi Anthea and Birding-aussers,

An interesting situation Anthea! I have had recent similar experiences on
Sydney's Northern Beaches. Because of the various sub adult plumage stages
these two cuckoos go through I often find it difficult to tell which is
which. My guides are not much help and I don't have direct access to HANZAB.
To me the grey eye ring is diagnostic as I have seen some fairly young
Fan-tails with a discernable yellow eye rings. I am not so sure about the
square tail, it depends on your viewpoint, if you are looking at the tail
from the rear of a F-t C the tail can look square, if you look down (or up)
on it's tail it is rounded even if it is not fanned.

The first of the two cuckoos I recently had trouble with was very similar to
the bird you describe (incl. grey eye ring) and I assumed it was a Brush
Cuckoo. The second bird was seen yesterday and was dorsally similar to your
bird but darker on the underside with some blotching rather than distinct
barrs. It had a pale yellow eye ring so I choose Fan-tailed Cuckoo. At a
quick glance both birds were very similar.

I would welcome any discussion on this matter.

Bruce Cox.

Anthea Flemming said:
>   When we moved on a short distance, Philip found a young cuckoo perched
> about eight or nine feet up in a Red Gum over Hymenanthera shrubs.  I
> would have said it was a Fan-tailed Cuckoo, but Philip noticed that its
> tail was rather square, so suggested it could be a Brush Cuckoo.  It was
> generally a fairly dark grey-brown with no marked mottling on its back.
> The zig-zag marks on the tail were strongly marked and noticeable.  The
> breast and underside were marked with blurred fine dark bars, over light
> grey,but there was not much contrast. The eye-ring was dark grey.  After
> checking various FGs and HANZAB,  I now believe it could have been a
> Brush Cuckoo.  Seldom recorded in the area if at all - Fan-tailed is the
> usual Cuckoo in the area, though becoming uncommon these days.
>    According to all the books, the Fan-tailed Cuckoo has a yellow
> eye-ring in all states of plumage.
> Anthea Fleming
> Ivanhoe, Vic


To unsubscribe from this mailing list, 
send the message:
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the birding-aus mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU