Re: birding-aus Bird tourism and rangers

To: "Sean" <>, "birding Aus" <>
Subject: Re: birding-aus Bird tourism and rangers
From: Goodfellow <>
Date: Wed, 19 Jan 00 10:19:01 +0930
A few years ago I tried to get elected to an ecotour subcommittee of the 
regional tourism association. But ecotourism was the flavour of the month 
as the time and I lost out in the stampede.

But another reason for my failure so I was told, was that not long before 
I'd run a campaign against errant operators - believe it or not they were 
doing things like ramming crocodiles with boats to make them jump; one 
was chipping bits off 2 billion year old stromatolites at at Aboriginal 
sacred site to hand out as souvenirs. My letters were published in a 
couple of dozen magazines and newspapers though not the NT News - the 
editor saw them as 'defamatory!' 

The tourism industry here was furious.  I was warned off, threatened.  
One operator went around telling visitors not to go out with me as I was 
'mad' (apparently the reason was that I took people to the sewage ponds 
and only a madwoman would do that! But I got off lightly.  Another fellow 
in the industry who tried to introduce some change had his vehicles' 
tyres slashed, several times I believe, and eventually went out of 

Things are changing although not as fast as I'd like.  When a pylon 
holding an osprey's nest was removed from the mangroves at Stuart Park 
last year I protested to a man who'd been a senior officer in the NT 
Tourist Commission and now works for the Minister for Tourism.His 
response?  "Who would want an untidy thing like that hanging over their 
backyard?" The bird then went and built a nest in a pylon above a busy 
highway where everyone could see it; the NT News ran a story in response 
to queries, Sea Scouts took it on board and with the help of sponsors 
built and erected artificial nesting sites around the place. I think the 
birds are safe now in that any move to displace them would probably 
result in public outcry!
When the bottom fell out of the Asian market the NT government 
desperately wanted to attract American and European tourists so they sent 
off a delegation of pollies.  I fired off a letter pointing out how big 
the birdwatching market was and suggesting they tap into it.  Asking too 
much I believe of Shane Stone and the other bureaucrats who went.  Not 
even a reply.

Birdwatching is a huge industry overseas and has the potential to be so 
here.  For instance for the 25 million North Americans who travel abroad 
to watch birds, Australia and NZ are the most popular destinations after 
the Americas and Hawaii.  But birdwatchers are not highly visible, one 
reason being they tend not to use travel agents. This is understandable 
as many such people don't know what they're doing (one couple ended up 
being offered a typical backpacking holiday complete with rubber mattress 
trip down to Twin Falls).  And yet of the 25 million or so Americans who 
travel to bird, Australia ranks higher on their lists than any other 
place outside of the Americas and Hawaii.

For some years I've been trying to interest the  Australia Tourism 
Commission in birdwatching but again no interest.  Then yesterday I 
responded to a message from ATC who are having a forum on Japanese 
tourism in Feb. pointing out just how big birdwatching is there. For the 
first time ever I got a response to my email, from the co-ordinator.
"Your comments are valid and I have passed this onto the Industry Liaison
Dept who will be looking after segment travel.  Your comments will be 
on board for review in regards to the agenda format.  In the meantime if 
have any further queries please do not hesitate to contact me."

I'll let you know if anything happens.

Rangers run the gamut.  I've had some dear friends among those up here, 
and many whose level of knowledge I respect. Some, not so knowledgeable 
try really hard to learn. But others leave me dumbfounded like one who 
responded to cries of delight from birdwatchers at Nourlangie Rock, 
Kakadu when they spotted Chestnut-quilled Rock-pigeons, with a bored, "Oh 
those things are there all the time."  

But one man, a ranger at a wellknown local park took the cake last year. 
Friend Monica Yeung of Gondwana Dreaming approached him, and indicating 
the Aboriginal women nearby working at their crafts, asked if they helped 
in the running of the kiosk, and if any of their people were interested 
in working in tourism.  According to Monica the ranger was not only 
disinterested but made a number of unhelpful racist and sexist remarks 
along the lines of 'they'd be too stupid'.  So she told him that I was a 
friend and she'd get the information from me to which he replied, "That 

Now I happen to know some of the Aboriginal women of that area and I 
cringe to think of them trying to work with this man. The only way things 
will change is if  birdwatchers make themselves visible eg with a birding 
card like that proposed by Ian Temby. And anyone should jump up and down 
when they meet ignorance.  Up here in the past it's done little good; one 
ignorant tour operator officially complained about seven years ago is 
still in business and people are still making the same complaints.  But 
as I said, times are changing.  


To unsubscribe from this list, please send a message to

Include ONLY "unsubscribe birding-aus" in the message body (without the

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
  • Re: birding-aus Bird tourism and rangers, Goodfellow <=

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the birding-aus mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU