naturerecordists
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: ATRAC propaganda (was False ATRAC / MP3 artifacts)

Subject: Re: ATRAC propaganda (was False ATRAC / MP3 artifacts)
From:
Date: Wed, 21 Jul 2004 01:09:39 +0200 (MEST)
Walt,

I will now leave you alone and no longer waste my time on your mad phantasy=
.

Raimund



> From: Gianni Pavan <>
>
> >
> > Raimund,
> >          it is difficult to say something about the spectrogram you
> show:
> >
> >
> >>http://www.avisoft-saslab.com/compression/MDtest2MD.gif
> >>
> >>As you can see clearly on the waveform, there is for sure no clipping a=
t
> >>that location (the amplitude is much higher at the start of the call).
> >
> >
> > The "missing" harmonic maybe an artifact or maybe it is real.
>
> A pattern of anything like that nature has not occurred in all the years=

> I've been staring at sonograms of my minidisc recordings. I'd say to be
> ATRAC caused would make it extremely rare, with odds of occurring like
> winning the big lottery.
>
> I vote for processing artifact of some kind. It covers 0.35 seconds,
> that's over 15,000 samples wide. A huge amount of time in sound
> processing. ATRAC works in much shorter frames, and has little
> connection downstream like that. The premise proposed that the louder
> sound just before blanked it out would simply not occur, no connection.
>
> Even as a processing artifact it's interesting, and rare. The sonogram
> is very crude, and the explanation may be in there.
>
> > To have a better view of what ATRAC or MP3 do on a recording I suggest
> to
> > plot the spectrogram with 96dB or more dynamic range: this way it is
> easy
> > to see all the portions that are cut by the system because "believed"
> > unaudible for the human ear. If the recording has a background noise, a=
s
> > most nature recordings have, you'll easily see (and demonstrate) all th=
e
> > "holes" created by psychoacoustic compression.
> > I'm sorry I can't now post an example.
>
> Doing this can also induce all kinds of artifacts. Remember the analysis=

> software is a form of sound compression. It's extremely crude, and has
> artifacts much bigger than those of a very highly refined compression
> like ATRAC. At one point one of the shareware programs that floated
> around would make a sonogram for you, a pretty good sonogram. But, the
> fun part was it would also take a sonogram and convert it back to sound.=

> Fun to play with, but a single round would produce really poor sound
> compared to the original. Yes going both ways probably at least doubled
> the errors. That would produce obvious holes easily.
>
> I should note that I've managed a few times to produce ATRAC/no ATRAC
> soundfile pairs a few times that were in accurate enough sync along
> their entire length to produce a quality difference file. In other
> words, what ATRAC removed. I did not find a batch of holes, selected
> faint calls hidden by louder foreground or anything like that when I
> looked by sonogram and listened to the sound in those difference files.
> What I did find was that the difference file was a very close duplicate
> of either the ATRAC or no ATRAC file, but at a much reduced volume.
> Especially obvious if the gain is matched to the original files. In
> other words what ATRAC removed was what it left (and what it left was
> what it removed, kind of zen like). Exactly what we want a quality
> compressor to do if you think about it. Note the only ATRAC I've managed=

> to test this way was ATRAC 4, not the ATRAC 4.5 I now use.
>
> So, the idea that there are "holes" from ATRAC seems a little strange.
> Such holes would be very obvious in a difference file. In my experience
> that not only are not obvious, but appear to not exist.
>
> Walt
> 
>
>
>
>
> "Microphones are not ears,
> Loudspeakers are not birds,
> A listening room is not nature."
> Klas Strandberg
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>=20
>



________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
  • Re: ATRAC propaganda (was False ATRAC / MP3 artifacts), recordingbird <=
Admin

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the naturerecordists mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU