birding-aus

"Super Trawler" and pelagic fishing impacts on seabirds

To: 'birding-aus' <>
Subject: "Super Trawler" and pelagic fishing impacts on seabirds
From: Ian May <>
Date: Thu, 20 Sep 2012 09:56:12 +1000
Dear all

The announcement was made yesterday that the Australian Senate will back a recommendation of the Lower House of Parliament to ban the "Super Trawler" from Australian waters for two years while its potential impacts are studied. However it remains unclear if the 18000 ton fishing quota for the Red Bait/Jack Mackerel fishery still stands and if it does, the problem of environmental impact on marine wildlife continues and has serious implications for seabirds. From this saga emerge two major environmental issues that require resolution. 1 The use of trawlers with a capacity to rapidly cause fish depletion. 2. The Australian Fisheries Management Authority (AFMA) procedures to establish the Total Allowable Catch (TAC) and their science used to assess environmental impact.

During spring and summer, Short-tailed Shearwater occur along the east coast of Tasmania in huge numbers from Flinders Island south to Schuten Island often forming massive rafts of swimming, diving and flying birds feeding vigorously in the vicinity of vast schools of fish found at depths from near surface to 100 metres or more below. Sometimes these shearwater flocks are so large and dense; their mass creates a local wind break where surface winds approaching 25 knots are reduced to velocities of not much more than 10 knots with almost calm seas immediately to the lee of the birds. On a single day voyage it is not uncommon to locate three or more swarming flocks of Short-tailed Shearwater following the directional movement of the fish and sometimes there are a few Hutton's and Buller's Shearwater, Albatross, Gannets and other seabirds mixed with them.

When feeding in this manner the water is teeming with activity. The shearwaters frequently swim en mass to depths of 70 metres and more, feeding on small baitfish, plankton and the shredded remains of larger fish including mackerel that are also being hunted by even larger pelagic fish, seals and dolphins. Birds depart the scene rapidly when approached by a boat however more than two minutes later; some birds are still popping up from their deep diving exploits. We can observe this using high resolution colour sonar.

After returning to Australia in late August from their long migration, many Short-tailed Shearwaters die of starvation and exhaustion particularly when their arrival coincides with severe weather events common during this period. At about this time the "Roaring Forties" kick in and severe westerly winds prevail usually from September to January. This is when emaciated shearwaters are often found dead and dying along beaches sometimes in hundreds and even thousands.

Over the past four or five years, there have been a more noticeable number of large deep sea trawlers working off shore from the east coast of Tasmania. There appears to be a correlation between this increased trawling activity and the most severe wrecks of shearwater observed here over the same period. It should be noted that pelagic fish targeted by trawlers are likely to be the same food source that sustains shearwaters after their return to Australian waters.

We have been informed recently that the Australian Fisheries Management Authority (AFMA) has allocated a catch quota of 18,000 tons of the Red Bait/Jack Mackerel to a Tasmanian commercial fishing company, Seafish Tasmania. To harvest their quota, the company has brought to Australia the 142 metre "Super Trawler", F.V. Margiris now renamed Abel Tasman, a ship built to harvest vast quantities of fish. To help understand the magnitude of 18000 tons of fish, it is the equivalent of approximately 800 fully laden semi trailers. The commercial fish value of 18000 tons of fish? The catch is worth 18 million dollars for every dollar per kilo obtained from the sale of the fish. The actual value of the product has not been confirmed but some commercial fisherman say that a conservative estimate of Red bait/jack mackerel worth is @ $5 kg = 90 million dollars to the fishing company. About the lowest benchmark for fish value is the price of commercial crayfish bait which currently sells for approx. $2 kg.

When the roaring forties prevail, the east coast of Tasmanian provides off shore shelter to marine wildlife. But the shelter of this coast also offers an attraction to pelagic fishing operations. Fish depletion from trawling is a real threat to the ecological process. Localised fish stock depletion is very likely in this fishery and will be exacerbated by use of a "Super Trawler" that has capacity to catch so much fish in a small area of available sheltered waters.

Of equal concern are suggestions that the AFMA assessed TAC for this fishery is much greater than 18000 tons. There is information circulating here (St Helens, Commercial fishing centre of eastern Tasmania) that additional quotas have been allocated to other fishing companies. It appears that the significant depletion of marine wildlife food sources are a likely outcome and has not been adequately considered during the AFMA environmental assessment process relating to the Red Bait/Jack Mackerel trawl fishery. If this is so, existing science is inadequate and should be redone.

Commercial fishing in Tasmania follows best practice. It is a legitimate respected industry essential to the economy of the State however pelagic fish management in Australia is a different issue and its impacts on seabirds have crept under the radar. A more transparent system needs to be adopted We need publicly available relevant information that can inform us about the historical and annual TAC and also the current methodology used by AMFA to measure ecological impacts on affected marine wildlife so that we can have confidence in the system.

Please note I am not an anti commercial fishing activist. My point here is to highlight the urgent need to develop an adequate ecological assessment procedure for pelagic fisheries that not only considers direct impact such as non targeted by-catch including seabirds but also considers equally important ecological impacts especially food competition for marine wildlife. The risks of catching seabirds from deep sea trawling are probably minimal but the risk of locally depleting fish stocks that would cause mass starvation of seabirds is immense.

Ian May
St Helens Marine Services
1 Tasman Hwy (PO Box 110)
St Helens, Tasmania. 7216

Mob: 0428 337956

===============================

To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
send the message:
unsubscribe
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
to: 

http://birding-aus.org
===============================

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
  • "Super Trawler" and pelagic fishing impacts on seabirds, Ian May <=
Admin

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the birding-aus mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU