| 
  
  
     Hi Steve, 
       
      glad you mentioned it - I went along with the rest on Rose Robin
      by the fact of being clearly outvoted - but I have never heard
      Rose Robin make this call. I know the Rose Robin's normal song
      well - like a "dit dit-dit-dit-dit deeeuw deeeuw" with the last
      two notes falling at the end rather than rising. At least that's
      what they sound like in Royal NP - I appreciate they can have
      different local 'accents' as well.  
       
      I'd like to hear a recording of this particular or similar call
      from Brush Cuckoo &/or Rose Robin to confirm the ID. 
       
      Thanks 
       
      Marc 
       
        
       
      On 05/09/2012 19:00, Steve Davidson wrote: 
     
    
      
      
        Hi Marc,  
           
          Tough call.  I think it's a Brush Cuckoo also, a series of the
          "pheeew-weee" calls they sometimes do.  It's a bit too harsh
          and "solid" sounding for a Rose Robin which is more reedy and
          plaintive and usually has more musical notes preceding the
          ''feear, feear" ending notes.   
          The first two notes on the sonogram are the loudest and most
          telling in terms of supporting Brush Cuckoo as the vocalist. 
           
          Hope that helps! 
           
          Cheers, Steve 
        
        
        Steve Davidson 
          The
            Melbourne Birder 
          www.themelbournebirder.com 
          +61 431 530 631 
          
     
     
  
 |  
 ===============================
To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
send the message:
unsubscribe
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
to: 
http://birding-aus.org
=============================== 
 |