RE: Fw: Red-tailed Black Cockatoo- Toonumbar NP

["Ian & Carla Jackett" <>]

Hello Greg and Steve,

It seems I have been getting a bit of fan mail lately!  

Joking aside, It seems with all the information passed on to me about the
RTBC in the past few days, that I would have to agree my ID cannot be
substantiated from a call on a CD that may not be comprehensive or fully
accurate in description.  I had nothing else to go on at the time and as I
said earlier, it fit the call as best as I could tell. The RTBC is out of my
home range so I might have been better off asking a few more questions
first.  Now that I am aware of the history of these birds, it does seem very
improbable the sighting was of RTBC. 

Thank you to all who passed on information and comments.  

Regards
Carla   

-----Original Message-----
From: Greg & Val Clancy  
Sent: Wednesday, 21 April 2010 9:34 AM
To: Ian & Carla Jackett
Cc: Birding-aus
Subject: Fw: Fw: Red-tailed Black Cockatoo- Toonumbar NP

Hi Carla,

Stephen Debus' comments on the calls of the Black-Cockatoos is below.

Regards

Greg