Andrew,
Hear, hear, couldn't agree more, well said, etc., etc., etc.. The world is not
full of absolutes, not everything has to be an extreme, most people can listen
to reason as long as you're not ramming it down their throats, and most of us
have been persuaded to modify our behaviour in some way if we have erred.
I hope these (obviously carefully considered) words of wisdom will strike a
chord in many.
Thanks for posting such a sane and thoughtful summary.
Regards
Tim Jones
> From:
> To:
> Date: Sun, 17 Jan 2010 21:28:34 +1000
> Subject: [Birding-Aus] birding ethics, and birding attitudes
>
> I'd like to thank Simon Mustoe for his very sane and sensible contribution
> to the discussion about the disturbance of the Ruff at Pitt Town lagoon by
> (we presume) over-eager birders or twitchers. We can add this discussion
> into the increasingly emotional and bulging birding ethics file. I'd like to
> make some additional points, about which I've been mulling over for some
> time. I expect they will spark off a new round of discussion and that's the
> intention, but my general observations are based on my personal experience
> only. They aren't directed at anyone personally. I have many wonderful
> friends in the birding community (hopefully I don't have too many less after
> this post), and I enjoy their company in and out of the field.
>
> I am 38 and have been birding for close to 30 years. In that time, birding
> has been a constant source of pleasure, contentment, and joy. When I was
> younger, it helped me become comfortable in my own company and helped forge
> my personal and political identity. I'm sure many others will relate to this
> experience. However, it's not the only thing in my life, nor the most
> important anymore, and hasn't been for some time. Birding is an important
> part of me, but does not define me.
>
> When I was 12 or 13, I was lucky to meet some birders close to my own age
> (but a little older - crucially, they had drivers' licenses). They were
> cool. Birding was cool. Birding was fun. I wanted to go birding for a
> living. But that wasn't to be, and my life and career moved in another
> direction. Birding was to remain forever my hobby; a way to engage with the
> natural world in a positive and personally meaningful way. And still fun.
>
> Now I'm wondering - where's the fun gone? Simon summed up my feelings quite
> well when he wrote: "Birders are unique in that they value the environment
> but because we are cliquey, 'high and mighty' and offensive to outsiders
> (even those perceived to be outsiders within the birding community e.g.
> twitchers!)"
>
> Birding now comes with a sort of implied pressure. To record everything;
> submit Atlas records; BARC reports; to volunteer; you name it. All these
> things are undeniably valuable, contribute to our sum of knowledge and can
> be useful in providing information that helps persuade governments conserve
> habitats and/or areas of natural significance. What they shouldn't do is
> turn a hobby into a chore, which is what birding could end up becoming when
> everyone is telling you that you "should" do these things. One shouldn't be
> made to feel like less of a birder if they don't. This is a separate issue
> to that which has sparked this discussion, but has increased my overall
> feeling of alienation from the wider birding community.
>
> Closer to the source of this discussion: there are things I did in my
> younger days as a birder I wouldn't do now. There are certainly times I
> would have crossed onto private land; other times I might have
> unintentionally encroached too close to roosting waders causing them to
> flush; and I know that on occasions I have used tape recorders to attract
> birds. These days I don't do the first, do my level best to avoid the
> second, and almost never employ the third. While there was always a loosely
> commonsense code of birding ethics, the subject was not in my recall as
> "live" a discussion years ago as it is now. Even without that, as you get
> older and more experienced most of us hopefully become wiser, more
> considerate and more aware.
>
> Many of the people on this list are relatively new to birding. I don't
> actually think "naming and shaming" those that make mistakes of the kind
> witnessed by Mark is going to do very much to prevent poor birding behaviour
> in the future. It might help release some angst, but I query its usefulness
> as a re-education tool. Rather than work ourselves into a foaming lather,
> maybe we could remind ourselves: we are all birders of one kind of another,
> most of us do care about the environment of which our birds and other native
> animals are a part, and demonstrate the way things should be done by example
> and through civilised discussion. That to me is a kind of good contagious
> virus.
>
> Could we please take a step back from all this self-righteousness. I am not
> seeking to defend anyone who causes harm to a bird's welfare by their
> actions and I understand the frustration and anger that causes, but making
> outcasts of people who should be our friends won't solve the problem. We
> ought to be trying to find ways of encouraging more people to take up
> birding in a way that gives them the maximum amount of enjoyment while
> causing the minimum possible disruption to the environment. A prevailing
> attitude of moralistic high-handedness is no way to achieve that goal.
>
> Andrew Stafford
>
>
> ===============================
> www.birding-aus.org
> birding-aus.blogspot.com
>
> To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
> send the message:
> unsubscribe
> (in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
> to:
> ===============================
_________________________________________________________________
View photos of singles in your area! Browse profiles for FREE
http://clk.atdmt.com/NMN/go/150855801/direct/01/==============================www.birding-aus.org
birding-aus.blogspot.com
To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
send the message:
unsubscribe
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
to:
=============================
|
