Gooday Birders
Peter
Among your good ideas for FG's I would especially like to see the quick
index to bird groups ie ducks, wrens, finches, cockatoos, falcons etc
in
the inside cover and I would love to see a colour chart. Is there an
internationally accepted bird colour chart available? There must be.
Greg Little
-----Original Message-----
From:
On Behalf Of Bob Forsyth
Sent: Thursday, 8 March 2007 5:17 PM
To: Messages Birding-aus
Subject: [Birding-Aus] Field Guide Requirements-- some thoughts
G'day all,
Peter Cooper wrote 28/02/2007 " ... I think we need a new web site
called 'Australian Birds From Below and Behind'..."
that prompted me to post a few words about the design of Field Guides.
Novice Birdos rely 100% on Field Guides (FGs) & thus their ease of use
is essential.
Australia is very fortunate to have a number of very good Field Guides
to Bird Identification
.. although texts over 1Kg such as Pizzey & Knight, and Morcombe barely
qualify as Field Guides
My latest versions include >
- Morcombe, FG to Australian Birds
- Morcombe, FG to Australian Birds, Complete Compact Edition, 2006,
lightweight edition
- Pizzey & Doyle, FG to Birds of Australia, revised edition 1991
- Pizzey & Knight, FG to Birds of Australia,1st ed'n, Reprinted 1997
with corrections
- Simpson & Day, FG to Birds of Australia, 2004, 7th Ed'n
- The Slater FG to Australian Birds, (Revised & Updated) 2003
Each has their strengths and consequently their followers.
... and probably many birdos will have their unique priorities on this
subject.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Here are a few thoughts that come to my mind >
STATEMENT
Field guides 1st priority is to enable the user to ID the bird ! !
Once the bird has been identified the user can then refer to one of
umpteen texts to read that author's version of the birds' sequence in a
Taxonomic listing.
SEQUENCE
- Look alike birds should be placed together. Slater does a good job
but Morcombe has Brown Quail & Little Button-quail 84 pages apart)
- Waders/Shorebirds should be in size sequence (or as close as
practicable)
ILLUSTRATIONS
- Illustrations for a particular species, should be placed opposite the
appropriate text
(except where grouped with the text, e.g. Morcombe Compact Edition)
Slater has a number of annoying exceptions to an otherwise good
layout
S&D placement of illustrations defies logic.
- Birds that are frequently seen on the wing, should also be
illustrated
as such
e.g. Quail, Waterfowl, Raptors, Nightjars
- Birds that are frequently seen from their rear (or below) should also
be illustrated as such
e.g. Crakes, Rails, Gallinules (i.e. Swamphen, Moorhen)
DIAGNOSTIC FEATURES
- Diagnostic features should be highlighted on the illustration, not
hidden in the text.
.. as they say "a picture is worth a 1000 words"
INDEXES
- The most frequently read pages, the Indexes, should be printed in
easily read font.
(and road tested by someone with failing eyesight .. in the dusk !)
- Scientific Names and Common Names should be listed separately,
- Common Names listing should be printed nearest the cover,
and highlight the start of each letter of the alphabet (e.g.
Morcombe
Compact FG)
- Quick Indexes (see S & D 7th ed'n & Morcombe Compact Edition) are a
welcome addition to FGs
(e.g. S & D 7th Ed'n, Morcombe Compact Ed'n) and should be located on
an inside cover
PAGE NUMBERS
- Page numbers should be in large bold print, and printed on the outer
edges of the page
IDENTIFICATION TABLES
- These are a feature of some International texts such as >
- Shorebirds, An Identification Guide, Hayman, Marchant, Prater
(p391-399)
- Crows and Jays, Madge and Burn (see p166 for Australian Crows)
- 5 others are listed on Birds Qld Web Page
www.birdsqueensland.org.au
COLOUR CHART
- I have yet to see any Field Guide include a colour chart ! Why not ?
How else do you define Rufous, Cinnamon, Scarlet, Olive ?
GLOSSARY & BIRD BODY PARTS
All FGs should include >
- Glossaries (example S&D 7th ED'n p346-349)
- Illustrations (example S&D 7th ED'n p1)
WEB PAGE
All should have their own web page listing any errors or extra
information and a facility to allow feedback of errors to the author.
The internet is here .. let us use it !
BOOK CONSTRUCTION
- Covers should be rugged. I find S&D vinyl cover perhaps the best...
but easy to get dog-eared.
- Glossy paper must be kept dry. Nor ideal for a book used in all
weathers !
earlier Slater editions could be dried out in a microwave (I have
yet
to test out the 2003 edition)
- The latest version of Slater has a clear slip cover which appeared to
be a good idea, but mine disintegrated after a bit of use
- Rounded corners seem to prevent dog-ears (latest edition of Slater)
OTHER IDENTIFICATION BIRD MONOGRAPHS
- A Quick Guide to some Waders of Moreton Bay, Litz-Tyne &
Venables,1996, QOSI/BQ
- Field Guide to the Waders, Condon & McGill. 6th Ed'n, 1974, BOCA
Both these publications provided relative sizes and silhouetes .. a
great idea.
I look forward to obtain Andrew Geering's forthcoming wader book.
- What Bird of Prey is that ? Beruldsen, 1995
Contains useful information but requires editing and reformating.
-The Birds of Prey of Australia, Debus, 1998
Contains useful information but the illogical placement and lack of
an index to the illustration disqualifies the book as a Field Guide
- Birds of Queensland's Wet Tropics and Great Barrier Reef, Nielsen,
1996
Introduces a unique method of listing birds within a unique
identification feature e.g.
Red or orange beak, yellow breast, white rump, etc. Thus a bird can
be listed under multiple headings. I found the book useful for this
region.
Well, I'll now wait for some useful feedback.
Regards from
Bob Forsyth
Mount Isa, NW Qld.
==========www.birding-aus.org
birding-aus.blogspot.com
To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
send the message:
unsubscribe
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
to:
===========
--
No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.5.446 / Virus Database: 268.18.7/713 - Release Date:
7/03/2007 9:24 AM
--
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.5.446 / Virus Database: 268.18.7/713 - Release Date:
7/03/2007 9:24 AM
===============================
www.birding-aus.org
birding-aus.blogspot.com
To unsubscribe from this mailing list,
send the message:
unsubscribe
(in the body of the message, with no Subject line)
to:
===============================
