birding-aus

sec: unclas BOCA's reponse to the proposed access changes at WTP, Werrib

To: <>
Subject: sec: unclas BOCA's reponse to the proposed access changes at WTP, Werribee
From: "Tania Ireton" <>
Date: Thu, 18 Mar 2004 09:44:56 +1100
Below is the document that the Bird Observers Club of Australia has
submitted to Melbourne Water regarding the new arrangements for bird
watching at the Western Treatment Plant at Werribee.

We feel the main points are the first two 'dot' points under the heading 
'Impact of the proposed Melbourne Water changes' on page 2 of the document.

It is important as many people as possible, both permit holders and
other interested bird watchers,  contact Melbourne Water to lobby for
continued access to these very special areas.
If you want further information the original plan can be found at
www.melbournewater.com.au/wtpaccess.

The address for your comments is: Melbourne Water, Reply Paid 4342
Melbourne 8060.
No stamp is required. These must be received no later than Friday 2
April 04.

Please pass on the information to others who may not be aware of the
proposed changes.
These documents,maps etc. will be on display at BOCA Head Office 183-185 
Springvale Rd Nunawading Vikctoria 3131 (ph 03 9877 5342) from Fri 19 March.
Thanks for your help.

Jill Plowright
President

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


12 March 2004



Mr Brian Bayley
Managing Director
Melbourne Water
GPO Box 4342
MELBOURNE  VIC  3001

Dear Mr Bayley

WESTERN TREATMENT PLANT
DRAFT ACCESS MANAGEMENT PLAN

The Bird Observers Club of Australia (BOCA) is pleased to provide the following 
comments on the Draft Access Management Plan for the Western Treatment Plant 
(WTP).

BOCA and WTP

The objectives of BOCA are summarised as:
Appreciation
Education
Conservation

To these ends, the Club provides its members with the widest range of 
birdwatching experiences, subject to its Ethical Birdwatching Policy to 
minimise disturbance to the birds or their environment; it provides 
appropriately-supervised educational activities for all age groups and it 
contributes through its publications, submissions and grants to a wide range of 
conservation initiatives, Australia wide.

For more than 50 years members of  BOCA have been appreciative users of the 
Western Treatment Plant (WTP) for their personal birding, enjoying the very 
wide variety of species to be found within its boundaries. The Club uses the 
area in its educational programs to highlight the variety and use of habitats 
by birds in changing environmental conditions.  Among other important issues, 
WTP demonstrates:

A number of different habitat types (open grasslands; wetlands of differing 
depths, salinity and cover; coastal mudflats and rocky foreshores, each 
attracting different bird species).
Changes in habitat in different seasons (e.g. dry and wet phases in ephemeral 
wetlands) and thus changes in bird species.
Movements of birds associated with changes in tidal levels and exposure of 
mudflats.
Significant changes in bird numbers associated with migration cycles, in 
particular the annual influx of migratory waders.

- 2 -


WTP is also a crucial site for regular monitoring and surveying of wetland bird 
movements.

BOCA acknowledges Melbourne Water's concerns over security, health and safety 
issues at WTP; however, it should be noted that in the 50 years or more of BOCA 
interaction with WTP we have no record of any such problems.

Appreciation of the work done by Melbourne Water

BOCA wishes to record its appreciation of the work done by Melbourne Water:

In maintaining the bird habitat values of this important Ramsar site and 
developing and maintaining the special birdwatching areas such as the 
Conservation Lagoons and Borrow Pits.  BOCA understands that Melbourne Water is 
proposing to create new birdwatching areas in the area of the T-Sections 
lagoons and applauds this initiative.
In establishing and continuing to use the Wildlife Consultative Committee (WCC) 
as a forum which enables organizations such as the BOCA to have input into 
policy decisions associated with the management of the WTP.
In setting up, administering and planning to upgrade permit-controlled access 
to the WTP for BOCA members and the Club's educational activities.
In planning to upgrade signs (warning, directional & interpretive) and to 
improve  roads, car parking and lookout facilities for birdwatching with 
stakeholder consultation on such requirements.


BOCA Objection to Proposed Changes to Melbourne Water access to WTP

The Club is most concerned with some of the planned changes by Melbourne Water 
for access to WTP.  These changes are at odds, in some respects, with the 
advice of the Wildlife Consultative Committee (WCC) and will significantly 
affect the activities of members of BOCA.  The Club believes that the proposed 
policies are unnecessary impositions on responsible birdwatchers who have used 
the WTP, for so many years, without problems to themselves or the WTP 
management.

Impact of the proposed Melbourne Water changes

Problems relating to changes to access as proposed by Melbourne Water include:

Closure of access to the east bank of Little River to general birdwatching.  
The east bank of Little River provides the best viewing of crakes and rails 
adjacent to reedbanks on the west bank, and the best visibility of mudflats at 
Little River mouth during certain stages of tide and day.  It also provides 
optimal morning birdwatching along the Little River and its mouth (as viewers 
from the west bank at this time are looking into the sun).
Closure to general birdwatching of the Conservation Lagoons and the Borrow Pits 
* at times these afford some of the best birdwatching on the WTP.  Continued 
amateur access to these sites will play an important role in demonstrating the 
value of Melbourne Water's management initiative in establishing them.
Closure of Ryans Swamp area except at times of inundation.  Comparison of wet 
and dry season usage of an ephemeral wetland area can't be made if access is 
only permitted when wetland is inundated.
Continued closure of Murtcaim Road through the north-east grassland areas and 
the new closures of Metropolitan Farm Road and 160 South Road west to the 
Princes Highway.  A wide range of species, especially raptors, can be seen in 
this area.


- 3 -


Continued closure of vehicular access to Werribee River from Old Boundary Road 
and new closure of access via 160 South Road.  BOCA acknowledges that access to 
the Werribee River may be eventually reopened through extension of the linear 
path along the Werribee River by Parks Victoria.

WTP, a  Ramsar Site

WTP has world-wide renown and a huge measure of respect as an outstanding 
Ramsar site.
It is Victoria's most popular Ramsar site for birdwatching and ornithological 
studies, and further curtailment of these activities would be very unpopular.

Opportunity for a Significant Tourism Asset

Looking to the future a plan could be developed to establish WTP as an 
international ecotourism venue, with an emphasis on birdwatching.  BOCA 
frequently receives enquiries from overseas and interstate birdwatchers about 
access.  The WTP is on the agenda for many international visitors, collectively 
adding millions of dollars to Victoria's economy.
It is recognised that this could involve significant costs for control of 
visitors, information and interpretation.  Volunteer assistance could be 
provided by BOCA and other organisations.  Given the potential returns to the 
State and the Werribee region, tourism funding of this development should be 
possible.

Given that 40% of visitors to Victoria pursue some form of nature-based tourism 
(ROYAL AUTO, Nov 2003), the infrastructure for WTP should be widened to support 
increased but appropriately supervised visits to widen public appreciation of 
the importance and conservation of wetlands.   This would be a mechanism for 
promoting Ramsar concepts (which is Commonwealth policy) and bringing further 
tourism dollars into Victoria.

Locations at WTP to which bird watching access is required

To enable full appreciation of the significance of the relationship of habitat 
to species variety and bird numbers, BOCA requires access under a general 
permit to the following areas of the WTP.
        
Austin Road and T-Section Lagoons
Paradise Road Lagoons
Ryans Swamp (whether wet or dry)
Lagoons between Chirnside Road and Little River, which incorporates Lake Borrie 
and its adjacent lagoons
Coast from Kirk Point to Little River mouth
Little River (both east and west banks and overlook of the mudflats at the 
river mouth)
Coast road from Little River mouth to the Borrow Pits
Conservation Lagoons & Borrow Pits
North-east grasslands adjacent to Murtcaim Road, Metropolitan Farm Road and 160 
South to the Princes Highway
Plantations along the western border
Werribee River
In addition:
Ideally for birdwatching it would be best if the WTP could provide access to 
the Conservation Lagoon area from the east as well as the west (e.g. via 
Metropolitan Farm Road and 65 West Road once the major reconstruction in the 
areas adjacent to 65 West is complete).  This could permit egress from WTP 
without backtracking the length of WTP if ingress was from Paradise Road (and 
vice versa).

- 4 -


Proposed Lookout Tower

BOCA supports the proposal for a Lookout Facility overlooking the southern end 
of the operations area.  If strategically located, this may give some views of 
the main cormorant-breeding and ibis roosting sites.

Proposed Access and Permit System

BOCA supports a permit system which enables Melbourne Water to record and track 
visitors to WTP.  The proposed swipe card technology should provide this 
capability.

BOCA agrees with the proposal in the Draft Plan that there should be two types 
of bird observing permits * a general permit and a special/research permit.

The Special/Research Permit would allow access to "operational areas" under 
strict conditions determined by Melbourne Water, including induction training.  
The General Permit would not allow access to operational areas.

While the Draft Plan recognises the need for special short-term permits for 
"overseas, interstate or other irregular visitors", such permits should be 
available through person-to-person contact, such as a telephone call: the 
requirement for a written application, while desirable, is very restrictive and 
not practical for persons arriving without prior knowledge of the permit system.

The Draft Plan shows a broad area as "WTP Operations".  BOCA questions whether 
all of this is required for operations, especially the land adjacent to Little 
River and the coast from Little River mouth to the Borrow Pits.

It is not clear why the Draft Plan proposes such strict controls over the area 
west of Little River which is outside the "WTP Operations" area.  Some specific 
issues relevant to this are:

The road on the west side of Lake Borrie is very important for bird observation.
Roads around T-Section and Western lagoons are important for bird observation.
Paradise lagoons should be coloured green on the map.

Consideration should be given to identifying the entire area to be accessed by 
the General Permit rather than delineating specific roads on the map.  For 
example, Figure 1 would appear to indicate that there is no "Bird Watching 
Access Road" to the bird hide on Little River.  Roads which are not available 
to Permit holders could be gated or signposted accordingly.

In closing, BOCA emphasises that WTP is one of the most important bird watching 
sites in Australia.  It is important from the aspects of conservation, tourism 
and good-will that the Access Plan optimises the opportunity for interested 
observers to enjoy bird watching at WTP, consistent with Melbourne Water's 
management responsibilities.

BOCA appreciates having the opportunity to comment on the Draft Plan.  If you 
require further information or clarification of any points raised in the above 
submission please contact BOCA President, Jill Plowright.

Yours sincerely



Jill Plowright
President

--------------------------------------------
Birding-Aus is now on the Web at
www.birding-aus.org
--------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this mailing list, send the message 'unsubscribe
birding-aus' (no quotes, no Subject line)
to 


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
  • sec: unclas BOCA's reponse to the proposed access changes at WTP, Werribee, Tania Ireton <=
Admin

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the birding-aus mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU