Hi birders
The field guide survey (#3) will close in just under a fortnight (15
September 2003). Thanks very much to those who have responded already
- 144 of you so far - greatly exceeding the previous totals in 1998/9
of about 70 each time.
Many of you will be interested to see the results from 2003 - they've
surprised me a bit so far.
I've noted all the comments about the methodology, and I acknowledge
the feeble statistical power and relevance of the life list measure
(but will use it anyhow where relevant!), the evils of twitching
(implied in some responses!), etc. Which guides you own versus which
you like best is not unnecessary duplication - some people borrow or
covet their favourite guide(s) but do not own a copy (or copies).
So far I have responses from all mainland states and territories -
mostly from Victoria, NSW, Qld, and the ACT; a smaller number from SA
and WA; one from the NT - still none from Tasmania.
Replies still welcomed - more will add to the statistical robusticity
of the end results, though 144 is not too shabby.
See the blurb below for how you can be involved.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
BIRDING
FIELD GUIDE SURVEY #3
During the two previous birding field guide surveys (FGS#1, FGS#2)
Lawrie mailed a questionnaire to the Birding-Aus e-mail list, inviting
subscribers to participate in a survey of birder field guide
preferences by answering six simple questions. The simple objective
being to see which field guides birders preferred, and why.
Birding-Aus at the time of the first survey (mid April 1998) had about
410 subscribers – mostly Australian (and with a heavy Melbourne bias),
but with a sprinkling of birders from most parts of the world. Lawrie
received 68 responses; equal to a 17% sample or about 1-in-6
Birding-Aus subscribers. In October 1999, he conducted the survey
again. This time there were 75 respondents from about 420 Birding-Aus
subscribers (about 18%). Most were from recreational birders, but a few
responses from professional ornithologists were also received.
A somewhat underdone analysis of the answers from FGS#2 can be seen at http://www.bluep.com/~oco/Fguide.html
It is our intention to provide something more substantial by way of
analysis this time!
Since the last survey in 1999, a major new field guide (Morcombe) has
become established, and Flegg’s error-ridden photographic guide has
been spruced up. We think it’s now time for a new survey – FGS#3.
If you participated in either FGS#1 or 2, please join in again. If you
are new to the survey – welcome! – and please send us your reply.
To participate in the survey, all you need to do is answer the
following questions, and e-mail the results back to either Lawrie
Conole
or
Alastair Smith
Nobody is identified in the web published results, and so privacy is
guaranteed – be as frank in your answers as possible.
1. Where do you live (Country, state, city)?
2. What gender & age bracket do you fit into? [M/F] [<20]
[20-40]
[40-60] [>60].
3. How many years have you been ‘birding’?
4. How many species of Australian birds have you seen (recorded on
your life list, if you have one)?
5. Please indicate which Australian birding field guides you own
(ranking in order of preference):
a. Cayley;
b. Flegg;
c. Morcombe;
d. Pizzey & Doyle;
e. Pizzey & Knight;
f. Simpson & Day (indicate edition);
g. Slater, 2 volumes;
h. Slater, Slater & Slater, 1 volume;
i. other ... specify.
6. What is your favourite birding field guide for use throughout
Australia?
a. Cayley;
b. Flegg;
c. Morcombe;
d. Pizzey & Doyle;
e. Pizzey & Knight;
f. Simpson & Day (indicate edition);
g. Slater, 2 volumes;
h. Slater, Slater & Slater, 1 volume;
i. other ... specify.
Please indicate if you use more than one field guide on birding
excursions (e.g. carry one and keep one in the car).
7. The reason(s) for your choices in Q5 & 6 (in 100 words or
less!).
E-mail yours answers by 15 September 2003 to:
Lawrie Conole
or
Alastair Smith
Results will be collated and published online during October – November
2003. The URL and launch date for FGS#3 results will be published on
Birding-Aus and BARD as soon as they are available.
REFERENCES:
Flegg, J. (2003). Photographic Field Guide to the Birds of Australia.
(New Holland: French’s Forest).
Morcombe, M. (2002). The Michael Morcombe Field Guide to Australian
Birds. (Steve Parish Publishing: Archerfield).
--
=================================
Lawrie Conole
Senior Ecologist
Ornithology & Terrestrial Ecology
Ecology Australia Pty. Ltd.
Flora and Fauna Consultants
88B Station Street
FAIRFIELD VIC 3078 Australia
E-mail: m("ecologyaustralia.com.au","lconole");">
Internet: http://www.ecologyaustralia.com.au/
Ph: (03) 9489 4191; Mob: (0419) 588 993
Fax: (03) 9481 7679
ABN 83 006 757 142
NOTE: This message may contain privileged and/or confidential information intended for addressees only. Please do not copy or forward without permission.
|
|
