Dear Kym,
What? if one leg was missing, and it is BROKEN, HOW IT STANDS?
Maybe the bird was resting in one leg (as many waders do) and that's why you
couldn't see it.
and the other leg Can Not be broken because it was standing on it!
YOU WROTE:
Today I observed a Curlew sandpiper on the beach at
Point Cook with one leg missing and the other leg
broken at the first joint.
Regards
Alex
From:
To: Kym Bennet <>
CC:
Subject: Re: [BIRDING-AUS] Curlew Sandpiper: Decline caused by leg
flagging.
Date: Mon, 18 Nov 2002 11:47:43 +1100
I agree. Banding does seem wrong to me.
Imagine the stress involved in being netted and banded, not to mention the
impact on future behaviour it must have.
This being my main concern, I fearfully mention this; but we do have
technology such as microchipping to reduce the need to alter the physical
appearance of the bird if scientific investigation is needed.
ALL BIRDERS should understand how important colour is in nature and more
specifically in the bird world. Waders being banded seems particularly
cruel since their legs are very close to their food source and colour on
their legs would definently scare away their prey. Birds are designed to
blend into their environment. Us humans are being very selfish wanting
colour on them for our own ends.
I ask for reponses on how this research is helping birds and if new
methods are being investigated on 1.\ new forms of tracking and 2.\ new
ways of actually getting tracking devices onto the birds?
I think this is a huge issue that all birders should take an interest
in......we are a country of the coastline, and we must respect our waders.
Peter
Kym Bennet <>
Sent by:
18/11/2002 12:12 AM
To:
cc:
Subject: [BIRDING-AUS] Curlew Sandpiper: Decline caused by
leg flagging.
Hi
Today i observed a Curlew sandpiper on the beach at
Point Cook with one leg missing and the other leg
broken at the first joint. On the broken leg was an
orange flag. It was a pittiful sight and got me
thinking about a recent message enquiring about the
decline of Curlew Sandpiper speculating if it was due
to a breeding crash.
The recent decline of Curlew Sandpiper is certainly
due in part to losses caused by bird banding,
particularly leg flagging. More than 50,000 Curlew
Sandpipers have been banded and leg flagged in the
past few years. The figures and statistics show that
this number (50,000+) is a sizable percentage of the
Australian visiting population of Curlew Sandpipers
and the recent decline correlates with the numbers of
birds banded.
At the end of each Australian summer, Curlew
Sandpipers are seen frequenting inter tidal estuarine
habitats coastal swamps and also inland lakes and
swamps across Australia. When one takes a close look
at these birds it can be seen that many have been
recently leg flagged. But when the waders return here
the following season, very few leg flagged curlew
sandpipers are to be found. It appears that most of
them die resulting from the bands and leg flags which
are clearly too much for these small birds to carry
through their migration.
Recently banded individuals can be identified by a
shiny untarnished appearance of any metal bands
present and also the relatively fresh appearance of
the plastic leg flags. Some Curlew Sandpipers are
manacled with four or more bands and flags. Rarely
does one ever see a Curlew Sandpiper with an aged leg
flag attached indicating that they meet their peril
soon after banding.
To those defending the undefendable, tell us please,
where are the missing 50,000+ leg flagged Curlew
Sandpipers and heaven knows how many other missing
small leg flagged waders such as Red-necked Stints,
Sharp-tailed Sandpipers and Knots. Just tell us, where
are all these missing small waders now.
The uncaring approach to this type of migratory wader
research must be questioned. Much catching, banding
and leg flagging is done without demonstrating any
genuine consideration for the potential harm that can
be caused. An almost unbelievable example of this is
published on one of the banding websites.
The site states that a number of Red-necked Phalaropes
were leg flagged and banded in the NW of Australia
recently.
Now a person who has any genuine concern based on even
the slightest understanding of a phalaropes pelagic
life history and their need for unencumbered movement
while swimming in predator rich seas would not
reasonably make a decision to leg flag such birds. It
would be obvious that the large brightly coloured leg
flags would impede swimming movement and also act as a
lure to attract predator fish. But these maniac
researchers did band them, apparently as many as they
could catch, and for what reason you may ask? Because
it seems, it was just one more rare bird for their
expedition banded bird list. Intrinsic reasons, not
scientific. Thats why.
If any pro banders are going to attack me for this
message, please do try and refrain from the usual
sycophantic character references about some of the
maniacs involved in bird banding. We only have to look
at the currency of people like Lord Geofory Archer to
know where that will lead to. What many of us want to
know is when will the amateur banding and leg flagging
small migratory waders stop.
Cheers
Kym Bennet
Carnegie, Victoria
http://careers.yahoo.com.au - Yahoo! Careers
- 1,000's of jobs waiting online for you!
Birding-Aus is on the Web at
www.shc.melb.catholic.edu.au/home/birding/index.html
To unsubscribe from this mailing list, send the message
"unsubscribe birding-aus" (no quotes, no Subject line)
to
_________________________________________________________________
MSN 8 helps eliminate e-mail viruses. Get 2 months FREE*.
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/virus
Birding-Aus is on the Web at
www.shc.melb.catholic.edu.au/home/birding/index.html
To unsubscribe from this mailing list, send the message
"unsubscribe birding-aus" (no quotes, no Subject line)
to
|
