Re: birding-aus Re: culled

To: Peter Waanders <>
Subject: Re: birding-aus Re: culled
From: Atriplex Services <>
Date: Wed, 18 Aug 1999 14:22:38 +0930
Peter Waanders wrote:

>  Hi all,
> Remember that the SA govt recently lifted the ban on shooting native
> rosellas, parrots etc.? I got a reply to my email to the SA minister
> for environment. It's full of political half-truths and "comfort-zone"
> talk and the most striking argument I found was the following:
> By removing the requirement for destruction permits in some areas, we
> become more strategic in our approach to management for conservation,
> thus strengthening our efforts to conserve all speciesYou can find the
> full text of the reply below. Regards Peter Waanders
> ==================
> Dear Mr Waanders
> Thank you for your e-mail dated 21 July 1999 to the Premier of South
> Australia, Hon John Olsen MP, regarding the removal of the requirement
> for destruction permits for common native parrots causing damage to
> commercial orchards in a number of districts. As this matter is the
> responsibility of my portfolio as Minister for Environment and
> Heritage, the Premier has asked that I respond on his behalf.
> Removal of the requirement to have a destruction permit is not an
> indiscriminate act. Exemptions from permit are specific to musk
> lorikeets, rainbow lorikeets, Adelaide rosellas and yellow rosellas.
> These species may only be taken within the local government areas of:
> Adelaide Hills, Alexandrina, Barossa, Gawler, Kapunda and Light,
> Marion, Mitcham, Mount Barker, Onkaparinga, Playford, Tea Tree Gully,
> Victor Harbor, Yankalilla, Berri and Barmera, Loxton Waikerie, Mid
> Murray, Murray Bridge and Renmark Paringa. Birds may only be shot
> under circumstances where they are causing damage to commercial
> orchards and vineyards and the only persons authorised to do so are
> the landowners and their employees or agents. In addition, the
> shooting of birds must not contravene the Prevention of Cruelty to
> Animals Act 1985 and the Code of Practice for the Humane Destruction
> of Galahs and Little Corellas by Shooting, the latter available from
> National Parks and Wildlife South Australia and local council offices.
> A species identification pamphlet will be available for orchardists to
> distinguish between exempt and non-exempt species.
> It is important to recognise that the species to which the exemptions
> apply are very common and cause significant damage to commercial
> orchards and vineyards in these areas. The taking of other protected
> bird species or these birds outside of the above conditions without a
> destruction permit is still illegal and people doing so will be
> subject to prosecution.
> An appropriate strategy to minimise the damage caused to a fruit crop
> is to implement a scaring, "reinforced by shooting" program before
> bird damage becomes widespread within the crop. Removing the
> requirement for destruction permits will enable commercial orchardists
> to act quickly and implement a damage control campaign. Depending on
> economic feasibility, region and the species targeted, this approach
> must be integrated with other techniques such as netting, visual
> scaring methods, trapping by professionals, timing of maturing crops,
> orchard location and the planting of decoy crops.
> Since shooting is an adjunct to a scaring program rather than simply a
> means of reducing bird numbers, it is anticipated that the current
> initiative will not noticeably impact upon the populations of the
> species exempted from destruction permits. Growers will only attempt
> shooting during the time that buds are forming or fruit is maturing
> and the birds are causing damage to crops.
> The removal of the requirement for destruction permits was carefully
> planned and considered with a view to improving the State&rsquo;s
> management for the conservation of native species by:
>   a. preventing the concentration of birds on orchards by enabling
>      orchardists to implement scaring and shooting programs when birds
>      first arrive, thus maximising early deterrent capabilities while
>      minimising the number of bird deaths;
>   b. enabling National Parks and Wildlife South Australia and
>      orchardists to establish a cooperative approach to pest native
>      bird management by having practical and integrated management
>      systems that are sensitive to more vulnerable species and that
>      provide sustainable long-term strategies; and
>   c. removing an administrative requirement that was time-consuming
>      and costly while not serving a conservation outcome.
> Controlling damage to crops by taking those species to which this
> action applies is not new, destruction permits were previously
> approved as a matter of course when damage was occurring. By removing
> the requirement for destruction permits in some areas, we become more
> strategic in our approach to management for conservation, thus
> strengthening our efforts to conserve all species.
> Thank you for your correspondence on this matter.
> Yours sincerely

Hi Peter.
I didn't (yet) get a reply to my email to Olsen, Kotz etc. but I was
wondering if you would like to write a slightly fuller reaction for the
River News, to be included under the heading:
"Local ornithologists unimpressed with Environment Minister's response
to  concerns about culling".
Alternatively, you could simply write a letter to the editor(s) of as
many papers as you like. I think the issue has already been aired enough
in the press for it to be common knowledge.
Atriplex Services (Pronounced A-tree-plex)
Environmental Consultants, Landscaping Contractors,
Native Australian Plant Nursery, Educators.

To unsubscribe from this list, please send a message to

Include ONLY "unsubscribe birding-aus" in the message body (without the

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>

The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely a compilation of material sent by many people to the birding-aus mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way. If you wish to get material removed from the archive or have other queries about the archive e-mail Andrew Taylor at this address: andrewt@cse.unsw.EDU.AU