Consumer MD quality
Rob Danielson <>
Mon, 9 Aug 2004 11:26:16 -0500
Waiting for the 744T recorder to roll out, I've recorded many hours
this Summer using several consumer grade SHARP MT-90 MD decks (and
all my DATS resting in peace). I've experienced 100% technical
reliability, MD is an amazing, _little_ medium.
I've noticed two qualities/differences comparing them to recordings
made with the Sony D7-D8/M-1 DAT recorders I've used for years. All
recordings were made with the same low noise mics and MP-2 preamps
and all transfers were made digitally.
1) The analog to digital processing circuits in the Sharp MD's is
understandably not as transparent. This results in a "harmonic"
structure in the sound that can be heard as a subtle chord of tones.
It creates a more "musical" sounding recording with broadband
original material (like location "air") but it also makes such
sources sound more similar than they are. The a-d quality in the
MT-90 is better than I thought it would be, but limited if one hopes
to do things like make subtle contrasts in post. Using the optical
digital input could get around the a-d lI assume.
2) Frequency nodes/artifacts. There are often some very narrow
frequencies that are not reproduced correctly or as accurately as
with non compressed 16bit. These narrow bandwidths are either
significantly attenuated or, instead of one tone, there's a blend of
two tones fighting for the same location on the frequency spectrum.
I've heard this at times with 16 bit recordings-- but its much more
pronounced with the MD recordings I've been working with. The dip in
response or discordant tone seem to create false tones that one has a
hard time balancing with EQ. I've encountered enough of these "spots"
now that I'm confident that they are somehow produced by the Sharp MD
I'm happy with the recordings and its likely that one could not hear
these quality differences when making analog MD transfers because of
the additional noise, distortion and a->d step. Of course, consumer
MD's use different a->d circuits than the Portadisc recorders and
this is important to remember.
Is it likely these traits occur with other or all consumer-grade MD
recorders? I really couldn't say as my use of other MD recorders is
limited. Best, Rob D.
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
The University of NSW School of Computer and Engineering
takes no responsibility for the contents of this archive. It is purely
a compilation of material sent by many people to the naturerecordists mailing list. It has not been checked for accuracy nor its content verified in any way.
If you wish to get material removed from the archive or
have other queries about the archive e-mail
Andrew Taylor at this address: