Good to see some debate going on regarding this species (as has happened in 
the past).  The New Atlas of Australian Birds has no breeding records for 
Queensland.  As Queensland Facilitator and SE Queensland Co-ordinator for 
the Atlas, I looked at a number of possible breeding records but they all 
turned out to be Leaden Flycatchers.  There were a lot of misidentifications 
of Leadens as Satins during the period of the Atlas.  I have looked at 
Bill's photos and agree with Chris' call.  For someone who is out birding 
much of the time, I see very few Satin Flycatchers.  Then it is usually 
between late September and mid November as they are migrating.  In SE 
Queensland I have seen them at Samsonvale (where Tom Tarrant saw one a few 
weeks ago), along the Duck Creek Road area near O'Reillys, and in the 
Woodford/Bellthorpe area.   We even had a male behind us a couple of years 
ago which was a bit easier to identify as there was a male Leaden about two 
metres away at the same time.
 Females are bloody difficult!!  In my experience in SE Queensland, male and 
female Satin Flycatchers migrate through separately.  Male & female Leadens 
hang around together.  I have had discussions on this in the past with 
people such as Graeme Chapman.
Roy Sonnenburg
Birding Services Brisbane
www.birdingservices.com.au
 Ph 07 32566952    Fax  07 32567692 
--------------------------------------------
Birding-Aus is on the Web at
www.birding-aus.org
birding-aus.blogspot.com
--------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this mailing list, send the message:
'unsubscribe birding-aus' (no quotes, no Subject line)
to 
 
 |