Remember the unknown bird I saw while on reservist training at Pulau Sudong.
After consulting an onithologist friend (S.Sreedharan a.k.a. Slim) and
comparing with better photos from one of Morten Strange's bird books, we're
quite certain its a Raffles Malkoha. I had a long close up of the frontal
view and the it matches nicely with a frontal photo. Its very common in SE
Asia but not so in Singapore. Perhaps this one is a stray from the Riau.
The bad news is that I'll have to wait till early next year for another
opportunity to go back there. I'll have to get a camera with zoom and some
lessons on bird photography.
Re. the bird on Pulau Sudong:
Sounds a bit like a male Raffles's Malcoha (P. chlorophaeus):
Size & Shape about 25cm length: OK
Body & tail like Koel but slightly smaller & more sleek: OK
Bill longish and pointed: OK, but what COLOUR was the bill?
Perched on a branch almost horizontal like a Koel and tilted its neck left
and right like one: OK.
Head and body (? upperparts, underparts or both): light cream colour with a
bit of fine streaks. Well, the Raffles' has a more chestnut mantle, might
occasionally have obscure shaft streaks on the feathers.
Underside of the tail checkered: What colour was the tail? Darker?
Chequered tail, you say. Black and white? What shape was the tail? Did
the feathers have white tips to them? Were all the feathers of the same
length or was the tail graduated (outer feathers shorter than inner ones)?
All these are important notes for proper identification.
Lower underside of the body near the tail (= vent) also barred but distinct
from underside of tail: Distinct in what way? Different colour?
Rest of the upper part of the underside (= chin, throat, breast) light cream
coloured: It is buffy to rufous on throat and breast in Raffles's.
Tailorbirds with full top half of the head reddish brown, no dark neck
markings: probably Rufous-tailed (O. sericeus), also has reddish tail. If
LOWER face is also reddish, then Ashy (O. ruficeps).
Sounds like an interesting site. You might want to suggest that a full bird
survey be done there from time to time!
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
To unsubscribe from this list, please send a message to
Include ONLY "unsubscribe birding-aus" in the message body (without the